Side-by-side technical comparisons.
Every comparison cites Florida Building Code sections, manufacturer specs, or public market benchmarks. No marketing claims — just the actual trade-offs.
Pool & Spa Choices
Resurfacing finish, pump technology, sanitation system — the choices that determine pool lifespan and operating cost in Northeast Florida's climate.
- Pebble finish vs Plaster finish
Pool surface finishes determine how long the surface lasts, how it feels underfoot, how it looks underwater, and how it resists stains from Northeast Florida's water chemistry. Pebble (PebbleTec, PebbleSheen) is the premium choice; standard white plaster is the baseline.
See the comparison - Quartz finish vs Plaster finish
Quartz-blended plaster (Diamond Brite, Pebble Sheen Quartz) mixes crushed quartz with traditional plaster, adding both lifespan and color depth without the exposed-aggregate texture of pebble. The middle option between standard plaster and pebble.
See the comparison - Pebble finish vs Quartz finish
Both finishes outlast standard plaster, but they differ on texture, cost, and visual character. Pebble is the longest-lasting and most natural-stone-looking; quartz is the smoothest premium finish with shimmer in the water.
See the comparison - Salt water vs Chlorine
Salt water pools generate chlorine on demand from dissolved salt (2,700–3,400 ppm), while chlorine pools rely on direct chemical addition. The water chemistry, equipment, and maintenance routines differ substantially.
See the comparison - Variable-speed pump vs Single-speed pump
Florida Statute 553.954 has required variable-speed pumps for residential pool pumps over 1HP since January 2010. Many older Northeast Florida pools still run pre-2010 single-speed equipment.
See the comparison
Patio, Sunroom & Outdoor
Cover type, roof material, screen mesh, room classification — the choices that determine how an outdoor structure performs across NE Florida's seasons.
- Screen room vs Sunroom
Screen rooms have screened (not glass) walls and function as covered outdoor space; sunrooms have glass walls and function as interior living space. The trade-offs span cost, climate control, and how the space is used through Northeast Florida's seasons.
See the comparison - Polycarbonate roof vs Aluminum-pan roof
Patio cover roofing comes in two primary categories — multi-wall polycarbonate that admits filtered light, or insulated aluminum-pan panels that block light entirely. The choice shapes the room's character, temperature, and acoustic profile.
See the comparison - Insulated panel vs Uninsulated panel
Patio cover roof panels can be insulated (polystyrene or polyurethane core between aluminum skins) or uninsulated single-skin material. Insulated panels add R-value, dampen rain noise, and add modest cost.
See the comparison - No-see-um (20×20) mesh vs Fiberglass (18×14) mesh
Screen mesh selection determines what gets through the screen room walls. Standard 18×14 fiberglass mesh stops mosquitoes but lets Northeast Florida's biting midges (no-see-ums) and gnats pass freely. 20×20 mesh has tighter weave that stops them.
See the comparison - Sunroom vs Florida room
The terms overlap but generally distinguish year-round conditioned interior (sunroom) from a three-season partially enclosed space (Florida room). Construction cost, code requirements, and use cases differ.
See the comparison - Screen enclosure vs Covered lanai
A screen enclosure surrounds the pool deck or patio with screen walls and a screened roof; a covered lanai has only the roof. The functional difference is insect control vs. cost.
See the comparison
Additions & ADUs
Build up vs. build out, attached vs. detached, ADU vs. conversion — the high-leverage decisions on a major addition or accessory dwelling.
- Attached in-law suite vs Detached ADU cottage
Both configurations create independent living space for family or rental income; the structural project, privacy profile, and regulatory framework differ. Florida's 2026 ADU rules clarified detached ADU permissions.
See the comparison - Second-story addition vs Ground-floor addition
The decision between building up vs. out usually comes down to lot constraints (does the setback allow a ground-floor expansion?), foundation capacity (will the existing foundation carry a second story?), and architectural fit.
See the comparison - Garage conversion vs Detached ADU build
Both add an independent living unit to the lot. Garage conversion reuses an existing structure; detached ADU builds from scratch. The trade-offs span cost, parking impact, and the unit's character.
See the comparison - Attached in-law wing vs Detached in-law cottage
Both house aging parents or adult family with privacy from the main household; construction approach, daily privacy, and caregiving access differ.
See the comparison
Kitchen & Bath
Material, fixture, and layout decisions that determine kitchen and bathroom remodel results — and the trade-offs behind each one.
- Quartz vs Granite
Both are premium countertop materials; the differences are in maintenance, pattern consistency, heat resistance, and visual character. Both are common in NE Florida kitchen remodels at similar price points.
See the comparison - Induction vs Gas
Induction and gas are the two performance cooktop technologies; both are dramatically faster than standard electric. The choice affects cookware compatibility, indoor air quality, and electrical or gas service requirements.
See the comparison - Walk-in shower vs Bathtub
Converting a tub to a walk-in shower is one of the most-common Northeast Florida bathroom remodel decisions. The trade-off affects resale, accessibility, daily use patterns, and water usage.
See the comparison - Curbless shower vs Curbed shower
Curbless showers eliminate the step into the shower; curbed showers use a raised threshold to contain water. The waterproofing, slope, and accessibility implications differ.
See the comparison - Frameless glass vs Framed door
Shower door style affects the bathroom's visual character, ease of cleaning, and cost. Frameless reads as more open and high-end; framed is more economical and forgiving of out-of-level conditions.
See the comparison - Framed cabinets vs Frameless cabinets
Cabinet construction style affects interior storage volume, hardware location, and the visual reveal between doors. Both are available at all price tiers.
See the comparison
Process & Contracting
Contract structure, license type, and project approach — what the framework around the work actually means for the homeowner.
- Design-build vs Traditional architect + bid + GC
Contract structure on a residential project affects timeline, cost predictability, and the homeowner's coordination burden. Design-build is increasingly common for NE Florida residential remodels; traditional architect-bid-build remains standard on larger custom homes.
See the comparison - Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) vs Fixed price (lump sum)
Contract pricing structures affect cost predictability, change-order handling, and who absorbs unexpected discoveries. GMP, fixed-price, and cost-plus are the three primary residential pricing structures.
See the comparison - Licensed General Contractor vs Handyman
Florida law distinguishes between work requiring a licensed contractor and work that can be performed without one. Most remodel scope (anything requiring a permit) requires a licensed GC; minor work without permits can be performed by a handyman.
See the comparison - CGC (Certified General Contractor) vs CBC (Certified Building Contractor)
Florida's two primary general-construction licenses have different scope authorities. CGC is the broader license; CBC has commercial scope with residential limits. The CGC license is the standard for high-end residential remodels and additions.
See the comparison - Major remodel vs Tear down + rebuild
When a homeowner wants substantial change to an existing home, the choice between major remodel and tear-down rebuild affects cost, timeline, lot constraints (setbacks, FEMA), and the home's character.
See the comparison